Are We Subjects or Objects? Bosnia, the Bosniaks, Zionism and Artificial Intelligence

Are We Subjects or Objects? Bosnia, the Bosniaks, Zionism and Artificial Intelligence
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Email

Enver Rizvo share concerns regarding narratives of Bosniak scientific need and dependence.  He argues that there is an urgent need to question narratives tying scientific progress to pro-Israel business and political policy.  These narratives obscure the urgent need for oversight and discussion of AI projects aligned to Zionist figures and projects.  Such oversight, he argues, is vital for the ecological and political reasons as well as the ethical culture and identity of Bosnia.

On October 19th 2026, Prof. Dr. Nusret Isanović appeared as a guest on Oštristav, a podcast episode produced by the Bosnian-Herzegovinian media outlet STAV. According to the description accompanying the podcast, Isanović discussed the profound moral crisis and the abuse of religion, the misconceptions of contemporary society, geopolitical tensions, and the dangers posed by artificial intelligence (AI) in the hands of magnates. He reportedly warned against the illusions in which we live, while also offering a key to raising awareness through upbringing, education and culture. Nothing would have been problematic about this matter, had Isanović himself not, at one point during the podcast, succumbed to certain illusions, those in which he believes, perhaps wishes to believe, or wishes to persuade broader segments of the Bosniak population to accept.

What, precisely, is the matter? In one segment of the podcast, which was separately extracted from the full episode and published on STAV’s official Instagram account, presumably to ensure that its message reached the widest possible audience, Isanović expressed a whole series of highly problematic VIEWS. In this excerpt, Nusret Isanović states:

“Could we, for example, have had fifty PhDs in artificial intelligence by now? The Serbs recognized this. Do you know that the Serbs have hundreds of their best and most talented people pursuing master’s degrees, doctorates and postdoctoral studies in Israel? Because Israel is a country where the most significant expertise in fields such as nanotechnology and artificial intelligence is concentrated. Almost everything that exists in Silicon Valley can also be found in Israel, perhaps even in a more relevant sense. And people have recognised this. So, what I want to say is this: we are not subjects, you know. We have not been governing ourselves for quite some time. We do not make decide for ourselves.”

From Islamic Civilisation to the Israeli Model

In case there is any difficulty understanding Isanović’s message, it is worth reading it once again, if for no other reason than to recognize how he intends to raise awareness among broader segments of the Bosniak population. Isanović, namely, does not want the Bosniak people to fall behind the Serbs (a construct that is itself problematic, as it stems from a deeply problematic nationalist perspective), and calls for intensifying educational cooperation with the criminal Zionist entity of Israel. To understand the full implications of his position, however, we must first examine who Nusret Isanović actually is.

Nusret Isanović (born on October 25th 1954 in Gradačac) is a Bosnian-Herzegovinian philosopher, university professor and researcher of Islamic philosophy. He graduated in Philosophy and Sociology from the Faculty of Philosophy at the University of Sarajevo, obtained a Master’s degree in Philosophy, and earned his doctorate at the Faculty of Islamic Studies in Sarajevo. He previously served as dean of the Islamic Pedagogical Academy in Zenica and worked as a professor at the Faculty of Islamic Studies at the University of Sarajevo. His scientific research focuses on Islamic philosophy, culture, civilization and art.

It is particularly problematic, therefore, when someone professionally engaged in Islamic philosophy, culture and civilization, and active within the academic and religious institutions of the Bosniak society, ideologically aligns himself with Zionism, a political project whose historical realization and contemporary consequences stand in profound contradiction to the anti-colonial, emancipatory and humanist principles invoked by a significant part of the Islamic intellectual tradition- or, at the very least, ought to be invoked by it.

Zionism Among the Bosniaks

Nusret Isanović is not, however, the first among Bosniak intellectual to have gravitated towards a Zionist project that has, over the recent period, intensified its efforts to establish a presence in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Particular attention was drawn to an incident in April 2026, when Hikmet and Harun Karčić, founders of the Sarajevo Security Conference and sons of the late Prof. Dr. Fikret Karčić, a figure towards whom Bosniak Muslims feel a particular attachment, appeared in Mostar at an event hosted by Amir Gross Kabiri. The event was a promotion of the novel Itamar K. by Iddeo Netanyahu, the brother of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, organized by Kabiri, president of the M.T. Abraham Group.

Their appearance sparked public controversy, followed by the Karčić brothers’ denial of having attended the book promotion, claiming that they had entered the room by chance while waiting for a previously arranged business meeting with the management of Mostar’s Aluminij company. Thus, an encounter that raised a series of questions about social and institutional ties to Kabiri’s circle developed into a public controversy. The incident, however, was quickly forgotten and swept under the rug, while the Karčić brothers were effectively exonerated in the eyes of broader segments of the Bosniak public. Another section of the Bosniak academic elite came to their defense during those days, naturally interpreting the entire affair as an attempt at provocation or defamation, as Bosniak intellectual elites, constrained by their conformism, are unwilling, afraid perhaps, to see a larger picture.

Among those who defended them was Emir Suljagić, the current director of the Srebrenica Memorial Centre, who even argued that cooperation with Zionist circles was the only way to protect the status of the Srebrenica genocide, adding that, if forced to choose between Srebrenica and Gaza, he would choose Srebrenica.

Nevertheless, this is not merely a matter of isolated incidents, although it might appear so at first glance. What is at play is a serious symptom permeating Bosniak society and the public sphere, a symptom and a problem about which, as with so many other matters, there is not a lot that has been said. It is a phenomenon that could be described as the advance of Zionism into Bosnia’s public and social space, an advance for which Bosniak-Muslim intellectual elites are collectively, and through their networks, rolling out the red carpet. Let us therefore examine what this symptom reveals through Nusret Isanović himself. And since so many things in Bosnia and Herzegovina are frequently turned upside down, let us begin at the very end of the statement published in the Instagram video.

There, Isanović raises the question of Bosnia and Herzegovina’s political subjectivity, claiming that “we have not been governing ourselves for quite some time” and that “we do not make decide for ourselves”. The problem lies in such an uncritical acceptance of the proposition that we are not independent, because it effectively surrenders our capacity for decision-making, from the individual to the collective and state levels, to external centers of power. Independence does not mean the absolute absence of interdependence. Rather, it means the ability of individuals, societies and states to independently shape their own objectives, values and political decisions without having to subordinate them to the interests of others. When such dependence begins to be presented as an immutable historical fact, the very idea of political emancipation is lost, while responsibility for one’s own social and political processes is replaced by fatalism. In other words, the greatest problem is not that independence is constrained, but that the idea that it can and must be pursued is abandoned.

When taken as a whole, Isanović’s statement raises several interconnected questions that go beyond the issue of educational and scientific cooperation with Israel. As the above argument suggests, these concern Bosnia and Herzegovina’s political subjectivity, its relationship with external centers of power, the ideological and ethical responsibility of scientific and technological development, as well as the economic and environmental consequences of projects announced in the name of technological progress. It is precisely in these questions that the fundamental contradiction in his argument becomes apparent: while advocating an end to our own political and social dependence, he presents the Israeli model of technological development as an example to follow, without sufficiently examining the power relations, interests and consequences inherent in such a model.

From Political Subjectivity to Political Dependence

Isanović concludes his argument by asking whether we are subjects or objects of our own history. Yet, his own example of Israel exposes a serious contradiction. If Bosnia and Herzegovina’s objective is to develop its own scientific, educational and technological independence, why is a state presented as a model when its development is viewed almost exclusively through the prism of technological superiority, without any critical examination of the political interests and power structures underpinning it? Freedom and independence cannot be measured solely by the number of PhDs, technology companies or international partnerships. These also assume the ability to independently determine one’s own social priorities, ethical boundaries and political principles. Subjectivity founded upon the uncritical imitation of foreign models can easily turn into a new form of dependence.

Israel as a Technological Model and a Political Contradiction

It is particularly problematic that Isanović singles out Israel as a country in which the most significant scientific and technological potential is concentrated, presenting Israeli universities and research centers as an example the Bosniaks should follow. What is entirely absent from his argument, however, is the question of the political responsibility of science and technology. Israel is not merely a technologically advanced state; it is also a state whose military, intelligence and surveillance capabilities are deeply intertwined with technological development. The use of artificial intelligence in military operations and the surveillance of the Palestinian population is of particular importance. This does not mean that all academic cooperation with Israeli institutions is inherently unacceptable. It does mean, however, that an intellectual who speaks about freedom, morality and independence cannot separate technological development from the political circumstances in which it takes place.

Artificial Intelligence: Scientific Progress or an Infrastructure of Power?

This brings us to an even more serious question. Artificial intelligence is not a neutral technology existing outside social and political relations. It requires enormous quantities of electricity, water, raw materials, capital and infrastructure, while its applications range from medicine, education and scientific research to the military industry, intelligence surveillance and the automation of warfare. It is therefore insufficient to discuss how many PhDs in artificial intelligence a particular country has or how technologically advanced it is. We must ask who controls the infrastructure, who owns the data, who finances the research, who generates the profits and for whose political and military purposes these technologies are developed and deployed.

It is precisely in this context that Isanović’s praise of Israel’s technological superiority becomes particularly interesting, given that the NOVERIX project is simultaneously being developed in Mostar. This data center is intended to serve the needs of artificial intelligence, cloud computing and other digital infrastructure. The project is being developed by the M.T. Abraham Group, which also owns Aluminij Industries and is associated with Amir Gross Kabiri. According to the plans presented, the capacity would be developed from an initial 50 megawatts to a potential 200 megawatts.

Here, the question of technological development directly collides with that of economic and political sovereignty. Will Mostar and Bosnia and Herzegovina develop their own scientific capacities, research centers and domestic technology companies, or will they primarily become a location where foreign capital builds infrastructure to serve the global digital services market? These are two entirely different development strategies. The mere construction of a data center does not mean that the local population will control the technology, ownership, data or profits generated by it.

The Environmental Cost of Technological Progress

This question acquires additional significance when the environmental dimension of the announced project is taken into account. A data center with a capacity of up to 200 MW represents an exceptionally large consumer of electricity. According to an analysis published by Oslobođenje in September 2026, the maximum planned capacity of Kabiri’s project would correspond to approximately fifteen times the combined electricity consumption of all households in Mostar. This raises questions about the burden on the energy system, the methods of electricity generation, the possible construction of gas-fired power plants and the project’s overall environmental footprint.

Water consumption is another particularly important issue. Cooling server infrastructure requires carefully designed systems, and any potential use of river and groundwater resources must be subject to serious independent assessment. On 26 September, Oslobođenje reported that Aluminij Industries’ existing environmental permit did not cover the construction of a data center and that the relevant ministry had, at that time, received no official information from NOVERIX concerning its construction.

On the other hand, the investor’s response must also be acknowledged. According to NOVERIX’s currently published technical concept, cooling is planned through dry coolers, with limited water use, without direct abstraction of water from the Neretva for once-through cooling and without discharging heated water back into the river. The company states that detailed environmental impact assessments remain part of the preparatory phase. Therefore, environmental risks cannot be declared proven damage in advance, but neither can they be dismissed on the basis of the investor’s promotional assurances. What is needed are publicly available, independent and verifiable data.

Kabiri, Israeli Capital and Mostar’s Technological Future

It is particularly interesting that this project is taking place within the business and ownership environment of Amir Gross Kabiri, an Israeli entrepreneur who manages Mostar’s Aluminij through the M.T. Abraham Group.  NOVERIX lists among the potential users of its infrastructure AI companies, cloud service providers, as well as high-performance computing for defense purposes on its official website. This, in itself, does not prove that the center will serve the Israeli military or any specific military structure, nor that its users will be Israeli companies. Nevertheless, it quite legitimately raises questions about the future purpose of this infrastructure, who will control it and whether it could be used for military and security purposes.

We must also raise the question of public interest: what benefits will Mostar and Bosnia and Herzegovina gain from this project? Who will control the infrastructure? Who will have access to the data? How many high-quality jobs will be created? And what will the long-term relationship between public resources and private profit look like? A technological investment is not automatically a developmental success as well. This is particularly true if its economic benefits are privatized while the potential costs of infrastructure, energy consumption and environmental consequences are transferred to the local community.

The Contradictions of Our Everyday Reality

There is another interesting detail that should not be overlooked. In the very same STAV podcast, published on October 19th 2026, Isanović warned about the dangers of artificial intelligence in the hands of politically and morally unaccountable centers of power, focusing particularly on American and Israeli interests, the company Palantir and the militarization of technology.

This makes his earlier praise of Israel’s technological development all the more interesting from a critical perspective. If he is aware of the dangers posed by Israel’s technological and military apparatus, the question arises as to why, in one statement, he presents the Israeli scientific and technological model as an almost unreserved example to follow, without simultaneously insisting on the ethical and political responsibility accompanying such development. The problem is not the recognition of a country’s scientific achievements, but rather the fact that its technological accomplishments are detached from the historical and political context in which they have developed.

Conclusion

Having presented all of the above, a fundamental question must be asked now: how is it possible that all of this is happening at one of the most sensitive moments, when the threat of renewed aggression by the Zionist entity of Israel against the Islamic Republic of Iran is growing, an aggression supported by the criminal American regime?

How is it possible that, at a time when figures such as Tucker Carlson are increasingly emerging in the United States, representatives of a nationalist, populist and increasingly anti-interventionist wing within the American right, which in recent years has positioned itself as an alternative to traditional American conservatism and its pro-Zionist tendencies, the Islamic Community in Bosnia and Herzegovina, some of its members and individuals close to its structures, including figures such as Isanović and Karčić, are increasingly gravitating towards Zionist positions?

What about the Bosniak right wing, who, alongside a significant portion of those who declaratively position themselves on the left and center-left wing of the political spectrum, appears to have no problem promoting Zionist values on the territory of Bosnia and Herzegovina? Let us recall that, just a few years ago, billboards belonging to the Israel State Chamber of Commerce, associated with Amir Gross Kabiri, were displayed throughout a large part of the city of Sarajevo. Following public pressure, albeit relatively limited, Benjamina Karić, the mayor of Sarajevo at the time, offered assurances around that same time that she had no connections with Kabiri, only for him to publish photographs of the two of them together.

How does this story about artificial intelligence unfold at the same time when an increasing number of details and scandals emerge concerning Milorad Dodik’s lobbying efforts in the United States, Israel and even Saudi political circles, aiming at strengthening the position of the Republika Srpska entity within Bosnia and Herzegovina, as well as securing support for its possible secession?

Where are such VIEWS leading us? Are Bosniak intellectual elites competing with Milorad Dodik in their eagerness to ingratiate themselves with Zionist circles? Where will ideas of developing cooperation with Zionists in the field of artificial intelligence lead us to? Artificial intelligence that is being developed in Israel, among other things, for advanced methods of warfare, as demonstrated by its use in the crimes committed in Gaza, Lebanon and Iran.

Are we witnessing a symptom, or are we already paying, and yet to pay, the price of the consequences? Where will artificial intelligence take us? Where has it already taken us?

Enver Rizvo was born in Sarajevo, where he completed his primary and secondary education. In 2026, he completed his master’s thesis entitled “Yugoslav attitude towards the Suez Crisis (1956–1957) through the newspaper Oslobođenje”. His research interests focus primarily on contemporary Middle Eastern history, with particular emphasis on anti-imperial and anti-colonial discourses and their historical, political, and ideological dimensions. He is a contributor to several history-focused academic and popular history platforms, including Historiografija.ba, Laurus Laslaeana, and Povijest.hr.  This article is a version of an article originally published in Bosnian.

 

 

Image of AI as a human brain by deepak pal, CC BY-SA 2.0

Bosnian flag Cloudconverter, Creative Commons CC0 1.0 Universal Public Domain Dedication.

Help us reach more people and raise more awareness by sharing this page
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Email