Daily Mail enquiry re Islamophobia conference and IHRC reply

Daily Mail enquiry re Islamophobia conference and IHRC reply
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Email

IHRC’s correspondence with Imogen Garfinkel at the UK’s Daily Mail newspaper.  The paper targets Prof. Saied Ameli and the annual IHRC, DIN & SACC Islamophobia Conference.

 

 

Reply from IHRC

 

20 November 2026

Dear Imogen,

Thank you for your enquiry.

Please note, for transparency we publish all correspondence with journalists in full, to prevent misrepresentation or selective quoting.

You are right in saying that Professor Saied Ameli is not attending the conference. He was never intending to physically attend the event; he will be presenting his paper by way of a pre-recorded video. He has been invited to present the paper in his capacity as the head of the Faculty of World Studies at Tehran University.

Prof. Ameli is a brilliant and sincere academic who has consistently taken an inclusive approach to his work. He has championed multiculturalism and sought to foster understanding between different worldviews, a position that has even led to accusations of being pro-Western in his own country. He has also been critical of the retreat of multiculturalism in the West.

There is, therefore, a certain irony in the fact your newspaper appears so troubled by his views, despite giving little indication that you have even bothered to read his research.

We suggest that you contact Prof. Ameli if you wish to discuss his work on the SCCR or the SCC or any other body that he may have participated in. We are not his representatives.

However, a few observations about your proposed comments:

Sanctions

You are correct in saying that Prof. Ameli has been sanctioned by Canada. That being the case, there is no legal impediment against him participating in the conference. As you are aware, Canadian sanctions have no force in the UK.

However, if accuracy is of interest (although we appreciate that it has never been an insurmountable obstacle to a Daily Mail article), he was sanctioned for policies said to violate women’s rights like “compulsory veiling”.

Yet Prof. Ameli is on public record opposing the enforcement of hijab in Iran (or in lay terms, “compulsory veiling”). He co-authored a report in 2006 that you refer to, and which was funded by Joseph Rownstree Charitable Trust, which recommended amongst other things the application of equalities norms by the UK government. This included facilitating uniforms and dress codes that made professional life more accessible for Muslim and other women. These were not original proposals, mirrored those of government itself, and were already being applied by institutions like the Metropolitan Police Service.

We are sure that an intelligent Oxbridge graduate such as yourself will appreciate the rather Pythonesque absurdity of sanctioning someone for supposedly advocating policies that he has, in fact, publicly opposed.

Furthermore, as a human rights organisation we adopt a moral and principled position in relation to sanctions that are essentially designed to silence people from speaking the truth.

Western countries have weaponised unilateral sanctions to punish countries like Cuba and Iran for resisting injustice and oppression, crippling their economies, devastating the lives of ordinary people and in the case of sanctions against the International Criminal Court and the UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese, trying to obstruct the administration of international law and justice, in an attempt to whitewash the current genocide in Gaza.

Regarding separate spaces, we are unsure what you are suggesting. Are you speaking about the proposals by the then London Mayor, to provide women only carriages on the London Underground to help keep women safe while travelling? Or are you referring to Germaine Greer’s contention that women should segregate themselves from men?

Islamic Human Right Commission Ltd

Turning to the accusation that IHRC chair Massoud Shadjareh has been investigated by the Charity Commission. This is simply false.

Mr Shadjareh is not a trustee of any charity and never has been. Therefore, his actions have never been within the regulator’s jurisdiction. Either your sources at the Commission are inventing things, or you have managed to misunderstand whatever scraps of information have passed for research at the Daily Mail. Neither possibility reflects particularly well on your journalistic standards.

As for your claim that IHRC Ltd works with refugees, this too is factually incorrect. IHRC Ltd does not provide advice to refugees / do asylum work, and, to the best of our knowledge, refugees do not apply for fee waivers. We are struggling to see how you managed to connect these particular dots, but evidently the exercise proved more challenging than anticipated.

We are not sure what collection of garbled information you have assembled to arrive at these conclusions. Going forward, we would humbly suggest that you check your facts and make at least some effort to understand the subject before making enquiries.

That would have the dual benefit of enabling you to ask coherent and relevant questions while sparing us the rather tedious task of second-guessing what you might mean, correcting your misunderstandings and spoon-feeding you information that ought to have been established before you started drafting your email.

Serving in the Iranian Army

We understand that the entire nation was involved in defending against Saddam’s illegal war against Iran. We are unsure why Prof. Ameli’s record is being raised.

National Information Network

Your second email focused on the National Information Network (NIN). We are unfamiliar with the NIN and therefore cannot comment on its workings. We would, however, make two observations:

First, you appear to be suggesting that this luddite sociology professor, whose life’s work has focused on media and communications, is somehow the architect of a complex piece of internet technology. And what is the evidential basis for this rather extraordinary claim? Essentially, the “trust me, bro” of some random researcher whose principal apparent qualification is having a Persian name. He doesn’t even try to provide evidence for his claims.

Honestly: do better.

Second, the UK, Australia and other countries have all been discussing internet resilience, emergency contingencies and the possibility of restricting access in the event of cyberattacks or other national emergencies. David Cameron even spoke to parliament about how to stop people communicating during emergencies. These are hardly novel or uniquely Iranian considerations. The prospect of connected infrastructure being disrupted in a crisis, from communications networks to something as mundane as household appliances, is a legitimate part of national resilience planning.

Yet you appear to reserve your outrage for Iran’s consideration of such a system, particularly at a time when the country is under attack by the United States and Israel. One might reasonably conclude that your concern is less about National internet policies and more about finding yet another reason to criminalise anything associated with Iran.

Lastly, I would like to refer you to our website ihrc.org.uk for the latest information about our annual Islamophobia conference. We trust you will find everything you need there. Drafting sarcastic emails, after all, is not without its occupational hazards. We are beginning to develop carpal tunnel syndrome.

Regards
Media IHRC

 

Both messages from the Daily Mail

 

Sent: 19 November 2026 11:02 AM
To: Islamic Human Rights Commission <info@ihrc.org>
Subject: Daily Mail: Right of Reply

Hi there,

I hope you’re well.

I’m writing an article, to be published this weekend, about how Saied Reza Ameli is delivering a keynote speech at your upcoming conference.

I know he’s participating remotely, but can you confirm whether the conference will be held in London? I assume so, given the location of your previous events.

Ameli is a controversial figure, given his past and present involvement in multiple Iranian state institutions, most notably the Supreme Council of Cultural Revolution (SCCR), responsible for overseeing the persecution of Iranian women by the morality police for not adhering to appropriate dress, and the Supreme Council for Cyberspace (SCC), responsible for Iran’s repressive internet policies.

Ameli has been sanctioned by the Canadian government, for ‘gross and systematic human rights violations in Iran, including through the lethal suppression of demonstrations across Kurdish areas of Western Iran’, and the two bodies he is part of, the SCCR and the SCC, have been sanctioned by the UK.

Given his affiliations – to bodies recognised as thwarting the general freedoms of Iranians, and particularly women – his presence at your conference on Islamophobia might raise questions. Given this year’s conference is themed around how AI poses specific danger for Muslims, Ameli’s affiliation with the repressive SCC feels particularly relevant.

If you would like to give a comment in response to the article, and Ameli’s participation, please do send it to me by 11.30am on Friday, 20/11/2026.

Below, I will list the statements I am including about Ameli, as well as the IHRC and the Islamic Human Rights Commission Trust – a charity which funds the IHRC.

Many thanks

Ameli was formerly the secretary of Iran’s Supreme Council of Cultural Revolution, which drew up the tougher guidance on the compulsory wearing of the hijab.
It was during Ameli’s time as secretary that the late Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi commanded Iran’s morality police in July 2022 to find women breaching the law by failing to wear their headscarves properly. Mahsa Amini, 22, died in September of the same year after being arrested by the morality police because of her ‘inappropriate dress’, sparking nationwide demonstrations which saw at least 476 protestors killed by security forces.
Ameli, who is still a member of the Supreme Council of the Cultural Revolution, was previously the Deputy Commander of Imam Sadeq Brigade in the IRGC’s Seyed-al-Shohada Division from 1997 to 1999.
The IHRC, a non-governmental organisation, is funded by a charity called the Islamic Human Rights Commission Trust, which is based in the same building in Wembley, northwest London.
The Trust was previously investigated by the Charity Commission due to concerns about its involvement in publications made and events organised by the IHRC. It is currently subject to a statutory inquiry by the regulator.

Ameli founded the IHRC in 1997 and was director of its Board of Trustees between 2006 and 2022.

He was co-director alongside Massoud Shadjareh, who still holds the role.
Shadjareh was investigated by the charity regulator in January 2020 after praising the Iranian general Qasem Soleimani, who was killed in a US drone strike, as a ‘martyr’ during a meeting at the Islamic Centre of England.
The centre subsequently received an official warning from the Charity Commission in 2020 and is now also the subject of a statutory inquiry after failing to comply with the regulator’s ‘Action Plan’.
The legal arm of the IHRC offers free advice to assist refugees.
Between February 1, 2025, and January 31, 2026, the fund assisted nine individuals with their leave to remain applications and saved individuals and families a total of £18,832 in Home Office fees and £16,000 in professional fees.
Ameli claimed after the Supreme Council released the guidelines on ‘chastity and hijab’ in 2019 that they were needed for ‘social health, protection of the family’.
He said that foreign television programmes were designed to ‘weaken chastity and hijab’.
In 2006 he was co-author of a book about the hijab and British women, based on research collected by the IHRC. Its recommendations to the UK government included a nationwide policy incorporating the hijab into work and school uniforms and having ‘women-only spaces in public places’.
Canada sanctioned Ameli for ‘gross and systematic human rights violations in Iran, including through the lethal suppression of demonstrations across Kurdish areas of Western Iran’.
Additionally, the UK has sanctioned the Supreme Council of the Cultural Revolution and the Supreme Council of Cyberspace.

Imogen Garfinkel
Senior Foreign News Reporter

Daily Mail

———————————————————————————————————————————————————–

 

Sent: 19 November 2026 4:03 PM
To: Islamic Human Rights Commission <info@ihrc.org>
Subject: Re: Daily Mail: Right of Reply

Hi there,

 

I am emailing to add a few more details about Ameli that I am including in the article.

 

If you wish to respond to any of them, please do let me know.

 

Ameli served under Ali Fazli during the Iran-Iraq war. Fazli, the former head of the IRGC’s Seyyed al-Shohada Corps in Tehran Province, was later sanctioned by the UK for his role in overseeing all of the police, Basij and IRGC crackdowns on civilians during 2009 unrest in Iran, resulting in hundreds murdered as well as thousands imprisoned and tortured.

Some experts believe Ameli was one of the ‘main designers’ of the National Information Network project, known as the ‘National Internet’ – one of the most important projects of the former President Hassan Rouhani’s government.
The Supreme Council of Cyberspace defines the NIN as ‘a network based on the Internet Protocol with switches and routers and data centres which allows for data requests to avoid being routed outside of the country and provides secure and private intranet networks’.
The ongoing project would create a domestic, government-controlled internet, in which the state would decide all content and access, according to the Centre for Human Rights in Iran. ‘In effect, the National Internet would create a locked wall around the Internet for users inside Iran, with the government as the sole key holder. Needless to say, as sole holder of the key, the government would have full access to the content of any account.’
Following Ameli’s appointment to the Supreme Council of the Cultural Revolution, Kaveh Azarhoosh, an internet policy researcher in London, told BBC Persian: ‘With the advances made in the infrastructure of the national information network, it seems that the appointment of an agent at the head of the Supreme Council of the Cultural Revolution was because the council is supposed to play a more prominent role in the gradual disconnection of Iran’s internet from the global network by advancing conservative cultural policies designed for cyberspace.’
He added: ‘Ameli is actually the driver of these policies.’
A decree issued by the Supreme Council of the Cultural Revolution showed that the IRGC, intelligence services and the police force had been given ‘maximum’ access to Iranian universities and their international partnerships, in order to acquire sensitive research from overseas.
Advanced weaponry, drones, aerospace propulsion systems, artificial intelligence and sophisticated warfare software are listed among the top defence priorities for the country.
The ‘strategic document’, issued in 2021, when Ameli was secretary, states that ‘professors, researchers and students’ should be utilised to secure these military capabilities in response to Iran’s ‘defence needs’.

Imogen Garfinkel

Senior Foreign News Reporter

Daily Mail

————————————————————————————————————————————————————–

 

 

Help us reach more people and raise more awareness by sharing this page
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Email