When we received the Daily Mail’s questions, we suspected this was part of an anti-Iran, pro-Israel propaganda campaign. After all, Israel is currently waging a war on Iran.
[See our response to their emails before the article here.]
The resulting article, which centres on the allegation that Professor Saied Reza Ameli was an IRGC commander, makes a fundamentally false claim.
Professor Ameli has never been a member of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), let alone served as one of its deputy commanders.
The publication of these allegations, without any basis in fact, reinforces our concerns about the agenda behind this coverage: to discredit our conference and silence criticism of Israel.
Professor Ameli is, of course, able to respond to allegations concerning his personal history. However, the following points are worth clarifying:
- Professor Ameli was never a member of the IRGC and held no rank within it. His brief military service was with the Imam Sadiq Division, a voluntary corps comprising volunteer clergymen, formed as part of Iran’s national mobilisation during the war against Saddam Hussein’s Iraq. He served in the defence of his country between 1986 and 1988. It is unclear why defending one’s country during wartime is now being presented as grounds for suspicion.
- Between 1994 and 2001, Professor Ameli was pursuing his postgraduate studies in Dublin and London, completing his Master’s and PhD respectively. He was not, as the Daily Mail alleges, the deputy commander of any IRGC unit during this period or at any other time.
- The Daily Mail also claims that “some experts believe Ameli was one of the ‘main designers’ of the National Information Network (NIN) project”. Yet the article identifies none of these supposed experts, provides no attribution and offers no supporting evidence for the claim.
Taken together, these allegations raise serious questions about the purpose and reliability of this coverage. We are concerned that they are being used to discredit our conference, intimidate those invited to participate, exacerbate the already existing racist and Islamophobic environment, and shrinking political spaces.
Our conference should be judged on its subject matter, the arguments it advances and the evidence presented by its speakers — not on false allegations about their personal histories.
Journalists, no less than the individuals and institutions they scrutinise, should be subject to the same standards of accuracy, evidence and accountability.

The Digital Anatomy of pro-Israel Propaganda
When we received the Daily Mail’s questions, we suspected this was part of an anti-Iran, pro-Israel propaganda campaign. After all, Israel is currently waging a war on Iran.
[See our response to their emails before the article here.]
The resulting article, which centres on the allegation that Professor Saied Reza Ameli was an IRGC commander, makes a fundamentally false claim.
Professor Ameli has never been a member of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), let alone served as one of its deputy commanders.
The publication of these allegations, without any basis in fact, reinforces our concerns about the agenda behind this coverage: to discredit our conference and silence criticism of Israel.
Professor Ameli is, of course, able to respond to allegations concerning his personal history. However, the following points are worth clarifying:
Taken together, these allegations raise serious questions about the purpose and reliability of this coverage. We are concerned that they are being used to discredit our conference, intimidate those invited to participate, exacerbate the already existing racist and Islamophobic environment, and shrinking political spaces.
Our conference should be judged on its subject matter, the arguments it advances and the evidence presented by its speakers — not on false allegations about their personal histories.
Journalists, no less than the individuals and institutions they scrutinise, should be subject to the same standards of accuracy, evidence and accountability.
Help us reach more people and raise more awareness by sharing this page
Featured Campaigns
Trending Posts
The Digital Anatomy of pro-Israel Propaganda
Are We Subjects or Objects? Bosnia, the Bosniaks, Zionism and Artificial Intelligence
Storytelling Afternoon: I’m A Cypress Tree
Daily Mail enquiry re Islamophobia conference and IHRC reply
IHRC calls for prosecutions after Rohingya genocide finding against Myanmar government